Loading
Loading
IPGATE AG · IP Portfolio A · Sub-Portfolio A1
Electrohydraulic brake booster without travel simulator — core pressure control patents
Overview
Portfolio A1 comprises the core innovations for the IBS Basic electrohydraulic sequential brake booster — an electrohydraulic braking system without a travel simulator. The innovations were developed between 2005 and 2010 and launched on the market as series products starting in 2013.
The portfolio contains 4 patent families with 19 patents and a total of 23 core inventions or independent claims in 5 jurisdictions (DE, EP, FR, GB, US). The foundational E87 family — with 624 forward citations from 50 patent applicants — establishes the basic principle of piston pressure control (PPC) and sequential MUX valve control that underlies all modern integrated brake systems.
Four patents from Portfolio A1 were brought before the Federal Court of Justice (BGH). In each case, the BGH reversed the first-instance decision of the Federal Patent Court and upheld the IPGATE patents — a historically unprecedented clean sweep across four consecutive BGH proceedings.
Patent Families
Each family addresses a distinct functional layer of the IBS Basic architecture, from foundational pressure control through fail-safe accumulator design.
PPC · MUXThe foundational patent for electrohydraulic brake-by-wire. Current-proportional pressure control, adaptive map-based piston position, sequential MUX valve control, and AEB. 624 forward citations from 50 applicants. BGH final legal validity (X ZR 111/22).
Brake BoosterProtects the core function of IBS Basic: the electric motor-driven follow-up brake booster with differential travel control. Over 100 million units produced worldwide. Three BGH victories (X ZR 91/23, X ZR 134/23, X ZR 133/23).
RegenerativeBraking system for hybrid vehicles with a multifunctional storage device used for both ABS pressure relief and regenerative blending. Provides controlled pedal force feedback during generator braking. Upheld by the Federal Patent Court (Jan 31, 2024); appeal pending before BGH.
Fail-SafeUses the existing spring-loaded ABS/ESP reservoir as a hydraulic emergency buffer in the event of a blocked drive or transmission. Prevents brake lock-up without additional components or external power. 6 patents in 4 jurisdictions (DE, FR, GB, US).
At a Glance
| Family | Priority | Technology | Claims | Specs | Highest Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| E87 | Apr 21, 2005 | MUX Pressure Control / PPC | 12 | 8 | BGH — final legal validity |
| E112 | Feb 3, 2009 | Electric Motor Brake Booster | 3 | 3 | 3× BGH — final legal validity |
| E117 | Sep 30, 2009 | Regenerative EHB Brake Booster | 4 | 2 | BPatG upheld · BGH appeal pending |
| E120 | Jun 2, 2010 | Fail-Safe Pressure Relief | 4 | 6 | Granted |
| Total | 2005–2010 | — | 23 | 19 | 4 BGH victories in 4 proceedings |
Glossary
The following nomenclature is based on the technical publications of IBS Technology (Brake Manual, 5th edition; IBS Technology, Leiber/van Zanten 2025) and is used consistently in all portfolio documents.
References
The technical fundamentals of the innovations documented in this portfolio are described in greater detail in the following publications.
Strategic Significance
All four patents from Portfolio A1 heard before the Federal Court of Justice (10th Civil Senate, Presiding Judge: Dr. Deichfuß) were upheld. In each case, the BGH reversed the first-instance decision of the Federal Patent Court — which had declared the patents invalid — in favour of IPGATE AG. This clean sweep across four consecutive BGH appeals is historically unprecedented in German patent law.
E87DE1 · X ZR 111/22 · February 13, 2025 · BGH — final legal validity
E112DE · X ZR 91/23 · July 17, 2025 · BGH — final legal validity
E112DE1 · X ZR 134/23 · September 18, 2025 · BGH — final legal validity
E112DE2 · X ZR 133/23 · August 21, 2025 · BGH — final legal validity